The Ultimate Creamy Sharp Cheddar Stovetop Mac and Cheese Recipe
Prepare yourself for the best, creamiest stovetop sharp cheddar mac and cheese you’ve ever tasted!
There’s a universally acknowledged truth: mac and cheese is the quintessential comfort food. But not all mac and cheese is created equal. While many of us have a nostalgic fondness for the boxed variety (hello, Annie’s!), nothing truly compares to the rich, nuanced flavor and silky texture of a homemade version. This recipe elevates a classic to new heights, focusing on the robust taste of sharp cheddar and the delightful simplicity of a stovetop preparation.
It’s no secret where my son Crosby gets his profound love of cheese. As a serious cheese lover myself, I understand the irresistible allure of a good cheddar. This Creamy Sharp Cheddar Mac & Cheese isn’t just a recipe; it’s an experience – a warm, hearty embrace that brings joy to every bite.
The Unrivaled Power of Freshly Grated Sharp Cheddar
Growing up, mac and cheese was a staple in our home, much like it is for countless families. However, as my palate evolved, I became a bit of a cheese snob, seeking out those rich, flavorful varieties that truly make a dish sing. And when it comes to mac and cheese, the cheese quality is paramount. This recipe specifically calls for sharp cheddar cheese, and there’s a good reason for it.
The secret to an intensely flavorful and incredibly creamy mac and cheese lies in one simple step: grating your cheese fresh. For this recipe, I purchased a block of high-quality New York Sharp Cheddar. You can find excellent blocks at most grocery stores or specialty markets. I wholeheartedly urge you to take those extra few minutes to grate your cheese from a block. It truly makes all the difference.
Why is freshly grated cheese superior to pre-shredded options? Most pre-packaged shredded cheeses contain anti-caking agents like cellulose or potato starch. While harmless, these agents prevent the cheese from clumping together in the bag, but they also prevent it from melting smoothly into a velvety sauce. Instead, you can end up with a slightly grainy or separated cheese sauce. Freshly grated cheese, on the other hand, melts beautifully, creating an incomparably smooth, rich, and cohesive sauce that is the hallmark of truly great mac and cheese.
Achieving Stovetop Creaminess: No Baking Required!
One of the many joys of this recipe is that it’s entirely a stovetop affair. No need to heat up the oven or wait for a bake! This means you get that incredibly creamy texture much faster, making it perfect for busy weeknights. The magic happens in a few key steps: creating a perfect roux and gently melting the sharp cheddar into a luxurious sauce.
I remember one evening when Crosby was particularly vocal during dinner prep – what parents affectionately call “the witching hour.” I ended up bribing him with pieces of the sharp cheddar as I tried to cook. He absolutely loved it, confirming he is indeed my child! If I can whip up this amazing dinner at 6 p.m. with a demanding toddler and no extra help, you know it’s genuinely an easy and straightforward recipe.
This recipe can be on your table in just 20 minutes from start to finish. It’s ideal for a quick, satisfying meal that both adults and kids will adore. Crosby gobbled this up for dinner, truly appreciating the bold flavor of the sharp cheddar. Its universal appeal also makes it a fantastic dish for holiday gatherings; I often make this each year for Thanksgiving dinner, and it’s always a massive hit!
Tips for the Best Homemade Mac and Cheese
Creating the perfect creamy sharp cheddar mac and cheese is surprisingly simple with a few insider tips:
- Don’t Overcook Your Pasta: Cook your elbow macaroni (or chosen pasta shape) according to package directions, but aim for al dente. It will continue to cook slightly when added to the hot cheese sauce, and you don’t want mushy pasta.
- Low and Slow for the Roux: When making the roux (butter and flour mixture), keep the heat on low. This prevents the flour from burning and ensures a smooth base for your sauce. Whisk constantly for about a minute or two until lightly golden.
- Gradual Liquid Addition: When adding the heavy cream and milk, pour them in slowly while continuously whisking. This helps prevent lumps and ensures a smooth, thick sauce.
- Gentle Cheese Melting: Once your milk mixture has thickened, remove it from the direct heat or turn the burner to its lowest setting before adding the grated sharp cheddar cheese. Stir gently until the cheese is fully melted and incorporated. High heat can cause cheese to seize and become grainy.
- Season to Taste: Don’t forget the salt and freshly ground pepper. A little sea salt enhances the cheese flavor, and fresh pepper adds a lovely aromatic kick. You can also add a pinch of mustard powder or a tiny grating of nutmeg for extra depth, though it’s certainly not required for this already delicious recipe.
Make It Your Own: Delicious Variations and Serving Suggestions
While this sharp cheddar mac and cheese is perfect as is, it also serves as an excellent base for various additions and customizations:
- Added Veggies: I love adding a bag of frozen peas at the very end. Simply stir them into the hot mac and cheese; the residual heat will cook them through. Steamed broccoli florets, chopped spinach, or even roasted butternut squash can also be wonderful additions.
- Protein Boost: For a more substantial meal, consider stirring in cooked, shredded chicken, crispy bacon bits, or even some savory pulled pork.
- Cheese Blends: While sharp cheddar is the star here, you can experiment with combining it with other cheeses. A touch of Monterey Jack for extra meltiness, Gruyere for a nutty flavor, or smoked gouda for a smoky depth can transform the profile. Just ensure the main cheese remains a strong, flavorful one like sharp cheddar.
- Spice It Up: A tiny pinch of cayenne pepper or a dash of your favorite hot sauce can add a subtle warmth and kick without overwhelming the cheese flavor.
- Toppings: If you enjoy a little crunch, transfer the finished mac and cheese to an oven-safe dish, top with panko breadcrumbs mixed with melted butter, and briefly broil until golden and crispy.
This versatile dish isn’t just a side; it can easily stand alone as a main course. Pair it with a fresh green salad for a balanced meal, or serve it alongside roasted chicken, grilled steak, or BBQ ribs. It’s also an indispensable side dish for holiday feasts, earning rave reviews from everyone at the table.
Storing and Reheating Your Homemade Mac and Cheese
Leftovers of this creamy mac and cheese are a rare occurrence, but if you happen to have any, they store wonderfully. Transfer any cooled mac and cheese to an airtight container and refrigerate for up to 3-4 days. When reheating, the key is to restore that luscious creaminess.
To reheat on the stovetop: Place the mac and cheese in a pot over low heat. Add a splash of milk (about 1-2 tablespoons per serving) and stir constantly until warmed through and creamy again. The milk helps loosen the sauce and bring back its original texture. Avoid high heat, as it can cause the cheese to separate. For microwave reheating, use short intervals, stirring after each, and add a splash of milk if needed.
If you love mac and cheese as much as we do, be sure to check out these other fantastic recipes: Greek Yogurt Mac and Cheese for a lighter twist and Broccoli Mac and Cheese for an extra dose of green goodness!
The Sharp Cheddar Mac and Cheese Recipe
Sharp Cheddar Mac and Cheese
Save RecipeSaved!
Pin Recipe
Rate Recipe
Print Recipe
Ingredients
- 2.5 cups dry elbow macaroni noodles
- 3 tablespoons butter
- 2 tablespoons whole wheat flour
- 1/3 cup heavy cream
- 1/3 cup 2% milk
- 2 cups sharp cheddar cheese, freshly grated
- 1/4 teaspoon sea salt
- freshly ground pepper, to taste
Instructions
-
Cook macaroni noodles according to package instructions, drain, and set aside
-
In the same pot you cooked the noodles in, melt butter (make sure heat is on low)
-
Add flour and whisk quickly to combine with flour, making sure not to burn (remove from heat if necessary)
-
Add heavy cream and milk and whisk mixture on medium heat until it starts to thicken
-
Once mixture starts to thicken, add cheese and salt and stir until cheese melts
-
Add noodles in and stir well, remove from heat
-
Serve with optional freshly ground black pepper, to taste
Nutrition
Like this recipe? Rate and comment below!
Are you making this recipe? I want to see! Don’t forget to tag me on instagram @buildyourbite and hashtag #buildyourbite with your recipe creations!
Be sure to pin this recipe for later and follow Build Your Bite on Pinterest for all the latest delicious recipes!
Did you make this recipe? Be sure to leave a star rating below!